Skip to main content
2026 Prospectus
The Healthcare ExecutiveExecutive News

Tax plans aimed at $1B nonprofit systems belong on the board agenda

A new Tax Foundation analysis prices out ways to tax nonprofit systems with more than $1 billion in revenue, and boards of those systems should treat their exemption as a strategic asset that needs active defense.

Tax plans aimed at $1B nonprofit systems belong on the board agenda

Executive takeaway

Ask management for a scenario analysis of the main tax options and an honest review of your community benefit reporting before the 2027 budget cycle. Then assign a board committee to own both.

Article

What was published

On October 22, the Tax Foundation released a menu of options for changing how the largest tax-exempt hospital systems are taxed. A week later, the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget added its own commentary. Neither is a bill. But the analysis does the groundwork a congressional tax-writing staff would need: a defined target, a threshold and ten-year revenue scores.

The proposals would apply to systems averaging more than $1 billion in annual revenue over the prior three years. University hospitals would be excluded, and the threshold would be indexed to inflation. By the authors’ count, 287 systems would qualify in 2027, and they hold roughly 85% to 89% of the sector’s revenue, income, assets and bonds. Estimated federal revenue for 2027 through 2036 ranges widely by option:

  • Applying the 21% corporate rate to net income: about $148 billion
  • An excise tax on net investment income: about $23 billion at 4%, rising to about $120 billion at 21%
  • Taxing benefits above charity care spending: about $64 billion
  • Denying donors a charitable deduction: about $32 billion
  • Ending tax-exempt bond financing: about $6 billion

Why the definition of community benefit matters

One option would recapture the value of the exemption only where it exceeds what a system gives back. The answer depends on how giving back is measured. Counting only charity care produces a score more than three times larger than counting a broader set of community benefits. The industry’s own numbers point the other way. An AHA and EY study for 2022 put the federal exemption at about $13.2 billion and total community benefit at roughly $149 billion. If Congress takes up this debate, most of it will come down to which spending counts.

Questions for the next board meeting

  • Exposure: Is the system above the $1 billion line or close to it? Has management modeled the options most relevant to you, such as the investment-income excise tax for systems with large reserves?
  • Evidence: Does the Schedule H report tell a story the board would defend in public? Can you separate charity care from shortfalls and other spending, and can you tie each to measurable community results?
  • Capital: How much of the capital plan depends on tax-exempt debt and philanthropy, and how would the cost of capital change if either became less available?
  • Oversight: Does a board committee formally own community benefit strategy, including the needs assessment and the policies on financial assistance and billing?

Earlier proposals of this kind have stalled. Still, revenue-hungry budget debates bring options like these back up, and systems that already have their documentation in order will be in the strongest position.

Sources

Quarterly Brief

Get the Quarterly Brief by email.

A practical executive agenda for hospital and health system leaders, four times a year.

Sent by The Healthcare Executive. Unsubscribe at any time. See our Privacy Policy.